2024 note: I’ve never roasted a pumpkin again. Don’t do it.

My boys are wondering why I am still practicing pumpkin pie. They are of the opinion that there must be a ceiling here – a moment when it’s perfect and I no longer have to get out my notebook, review my notes from past years and reach out for advice. It’s quite possible that they have also hit their limit for taste testing. Last night I nearly chased one of my son’s friends down on his bike with a slice of pumpkin pie before I let him leave the yard. I could see the glare coming from my 14 year old as he silently begged me to stop forcing his friends to eat pie.

We all have that one dish that eludes us, particularly dishes that are traditions and might only be made once or twice a year. When they are traditions, they feel even more important because you have the pressure to do right by your audience and your ancestors. For my dad, his holiday albatross is the oyster dressing at Thanksgiving. To this day, there is massive recipe review, a look back at hand written notes from the year before and an intense kitchen showdown while executing that year’s chosen ratio of milk to crushed saltine crackers. He’s been making it for decades and it’s still not perfect.

Rather than trying to make something perfect, I like the more fluid concept of making something better. Perfection just feels so final and boring. This recipe I’m about to drop on you is darn near perfect, but I assure you, you’ll hear from me next fall and I’ll still be making adjustments.

I hope my boys can see the parallel between my approach to pie and my approach to them. When it comes to life in general, perfection will elude and exhaust us just like that darn oyster dressing. I want them to understand that they are not searching for some unrealistic endgame (perfect grades/job/house/partner). Rather, life is the perpetual motion of making something better.

I could use this reminder when it comes to the pandemic. I’ve been fighting its constraints the last few days and feeling at a bit of a low point. The dream of having some perfect ending where the fog is lifted and we hop on a plane to see our exchange students is just that. Building back a post-pandemic life is going to be the slow process of making things better a little bit at a time. It’s not like there’s the pandemic and then there’s life outside the window waiting for us. This IS life now, so I have to take my own advice and keep my eye on small ways to make things better. Collectively, I know that somewhere down the road, there will be a point where all the small things will add up to a big leap forward.

So anyway, about this pie…

The pandemic, for all of its faults (and there are many), has given me the gift of time. It has also given me the motivation to end 2020 on my own terms – by making and eating as much pie as I want to. A shout to my pie people on Instagram gave me some great tips on how to up my pumpkin pie game, including grating your own nutmeg and the holy grail of tricks – making your own pumpkin puree. Since the pie philosophy here is the more simple the better, I had sworn off ever roasting a single pumpkin. However, the accolades for a pie made this way got the best of my curiosity. I went all in and purchased some serious Vietnamese cinnamon, fresh pods of nutmeg and made a visit to the farmer’s market for some pie pumpkins.

Here’s what I have to say about this. I had one ramekin of filling and three slices (they were small!) last night. I baked another one this morning and intend to eat more without shame. It’s the best pumpkin pie I have ever had and it might be a while until I try to make it better.

How to make pumpkin puree:

Preheat oven to 375 and line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Cut the stems off of the pumpkin, and then cut from top to bottom in half. Scoop out the seeds, scraping out as much of the strings as possible.

Place pumpkin halves face down (either way is totally fine) on the baking sheet. Roast in the oven for 45 – 50 minutes until skin is browned and very fork tender. Remove from oven and cool.

Peel skin leaving only the pumpkin meat behind. Using a food processor or blender (I used my Vitamix), blend mixture into a smooth puree. If it appears watery (there will be some liquid once the puree rests for a bit), use a strainer to eliminate some liquid.

For me, one medium sized pie pumpkin made about 20 ounces of filling (need 15 ounces for 1 pie). So, one pie per small/medium pumpkin. Filling can be made ahead of time and frozen by measuring out 15oz servings into freezer bags (press them flat, easy to stack).

Print Recipe

Pumpkin Pie 2020 Edition

This recipe evolved from my other pumpkin pie recipe on this site. I'm going to leave that one untouched even though I have made some adjustments that I want to keep with this updated one. The previous one is still good, more traditional and gives a bit of a fluffier texture. This is your pull-out-all-stops to impress someone pumpkin pie. 🙂

Ingredients

• 1 recipe 9 inch pie crust
• 1/2 cup granulated sugar
• 1/4 cup brown sugar
• 1 tablespoon flour (optional) If you like your custard to have more structure, use up to 1 tablespoon of flour
• 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
• 1 teaspoon cinnamon
• 1 generous teaspoon fresh grated ginger root It's worth it. Just do it.
• 1/2 teaspoon fresh grated nutmeg Can be generous with this too
• 1/4 teaspoon cardamom You can swap for cloves or allspice if you would prefer...but I encourage you to try!
• pinch salt
• 3 large eggs
• 15 ounces fresh pumpkin puree Equals about 1 3/4 cups (from the pumpkin mentioned above)
• 1 cup heavy cream

Instructions

1. Prepare pie crust, roll and plate. Can do this in advance and keep in the refrigerator for up to two days. You can also freeze plated, unbaked pie crusts. Wrap them well, stack and place in a large freezer bag. Make sure to use metal, tin, aluminum plates and not glass. Use the recipe of your choice or visit our crust recipes on the homepage of the blog.
2. Prepare pumpkin puree according to the directions above. This can also be done in advance and frozen.
3. Preheat oven to 350
4. In a small bowl, combine sugars, spices and optional flour.
5. In a large bowl, place pumpkin puree and beat eggs one at a time until fully incorporated.
6. Add sugar/spice mixture to the pumpkin and blend well.
7. Slowly add the cream until fully incorporated.
8. Pour slowly into prepared pie shell, removing any air bubbles.
9. Place on the middle rack of the oven and bake for 40-45 minutes or until the middle is JUST set. You know a custard pie is done when the middle just slightly jiggles. You might second guess yourself, but definitely take it out. Cool completely and then store in refrigerator up to two days.
10. If you are using a frozen crust, preheat oven to 425 instead. Place filling in the crust (take it right out from frozen) and bake on the lower rack of the oven for 10 minutes. Turn the oven down to 350 and continue to bake until done. This will help speed up the crust and get the bottom well done.